Browse the full Resources Index
Building practices in any given region develop, at least in part, as a slow response to that region’s weather history, and understanding this connection helps explain why construction details that seem unusual in one part of the country are simply standard practice in another. Minnesota’s construction conventions around roof underlayment, attic ventilation, and window flashing did not appear arbitrarily. They reflect decades of accumulated experience with a specific combination of heavy snow load, extended periods of subfreezing temperature, and hail producing thunderstorm activity that together create conditions less common in warmer or more arid parts of the country.
The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration maintains extensive historical weather records, including hail and wind event data collected through its Storm Prediction Center, and this kind of long term climatological record is part of what informs building code committees when they set requirements for a given region. The ice and water shield requirement at roof eaves found in the International Residential Code, for example, exists specifically to address ice dam related water backup, a phenomenon driven by the freeze-thaw pattern common across the northern tier of states. A jurisdiction without meaningful snow accumulation history has little reason to carry the same eave protection requirement, and many do not, which is why this detail varies so directly by region rather than being applied uniformly nationwide.
Hail climatology plays a similar role in shaping roofing material choices and testing standards. Regions within what is sometimes referred to as hail alley, stretching through parts of the central United States, see a higher frequency of large hail events than most of the country, and this history has influenced the development of impact resistance classifications for roofing materials, including the UL 2218 standard that rates shingles by their resistance to simulated hail impact using a steel ball drop test. Minnesota sits near enough to this higher frequency zone that impact resistant shingle options are commonly discussed during roof replacement, and some insurers offer premium credits for their use, reflecting an underwriting response to the same regional weather pattern that shapes the building code side of the equation.
Wind design values written into building codes also trace back to historical weather data, specifically long term wind speed records used to establish the design wind speed a structure in a given county or region needs to withstand under the applicable code edition. These values differ meaningfully between, for example, a coastal hurricane exposed region and an inland Midwestern location, even though both experience damaging wind events, because the frequency, duration, and typical peak speeds of those events differ by weather pattern. Straight line wind events and derechos, which affect the Upper Midwest with some regularity, produce different structural demands than sustained hurricane force wind, and code requirements reflect those regional differences rather than applying a single national standard.
This historical grounding matters during an individual claim because it provides context for evaluating whether a construction detail, or the absence of one, represents a defect, an outdated but once acceptable practice, or simply a choice appropriate to a different climate the material may have originally been intended for. A roof assembly built without ice and water shield in a home constructed decades before that requirement existed is not automatically deficient by the standard of its own era, and recognizing that distinction is part of evaluating construction and damage with the appropriate historical and regional context rather than judging every detail against current code as if it always applied.
This article is general education about how the appraisal process commonly works. It is not legal advice, and specific procedures can vary by state and policy.
Russ Lis is a working property insurance appraiser and umpire based in Minnesota, serving clients nationwide. Contact Appraisal Resolution.