Selecting the right appraiser, or agreeing on the right umpire, shapes the whole appraisal process. Because agreement between any two of the three participants can produce a binding award, the person chosen as umpire in particular can end up deciding the outcome. The questions below are meant to help policyholders, carriers, adjusters, attorneys, and agents evaluate candidates on substance rather than reputation alone.
Qualifications and Experience
Ask how long the candidate has worked specifically in property insurance appraisal, as distinct from general adjusting, contracting, or estimating work. Ask about the range of losses handled, including fire, smoke, water, hail, wind, hurricane, and related business interruption claims, and whether the candidate has relevant construction background that allows them to evaluate scope and methodology firsthand rather than simply relaying someone else’s numbers.
✓How many appraisals has the candidate served on, as appraiser and as umpire
✓What construction or building science background supports their evaluation of damage and repair methods
✓What types of losses and property types make up their experience
✓Can they provide references from prior appraisals, keeping in mind confidentiality limits
Estimating Platform Fluency
Most disputes over amount of loss come down to differences in scope and pricing within an estimating platform. A candidate who is fluent in the relevant software, understands how pricing databases are built, and can explain line item and overhead and profit conventions will be better equipped to produce a defensible number and to evaluate the other side’s estimate on its merits.
✓Which estimating platforms does the candidate use regularly
✓Are they comfortable reviewing and reconciling an estimate built in a different platform than their own
✓Can they explain their pricing sources and methodology clearly
Neutrality and Disclosure
An appraiser is retained by one side but is not that side’s advocate. A competent appraiser forms an independent opinion based on the building, the damage, the documentation, and applicable construction and industry standards, regardless of who is paying the fee. An umpire must be neutral by definition. Ask directly about any prior relationships, repeat business, or financial ties that could raise a conflict question.
✓Has the candidate worked previously for either party, and how often
✓What share of their work comes from one side of the industry versus the other
✓Are they willing to disclose potential conflicts before accepting the assignment
✓How do they describe their role, as an advocate or as an independent evaluator
Fee Structure
Fee arrangements should be transparent and should not create an incentive tied to the outcome.
✓Is the fee hourly, flat, or otherwise structured
✓Are travel, inspection, and report preparation billed separately
✓Is any portion of the fee contingent on the size of the award, which raises independence concerns
Communication Practices
Appraisal moves faster when appraisers communicate directly, professionally, and promptly with each other, with the umpire once selected, and with the parties who retained them.
✓How quickly does the candidate typically respond to scheduling and document requests
✓Are they willing to communicate directly with the opposing appraiser to narrow issues
✓How do they document and report their findings
Why the Umpire Choice Matters
Because an award becomes binding when any two of the three participants agree, the umpire is often the practical decision point in a close appraisal. A well qualified, genuinely neutral umpire, with solid construction knowledge and estimating fluency, gives both sides confidence that the eventual award reflects the actual loss rather than the leanings of whichever appraiser happens to align with them. Parties who cannot agree on an umpire should review their policy language for the fallback selection process, which varies by state and policy, and consult an attorney if that process becomes contested.
Disclaimer: This content is provided for general education only, is not legal advice, and appraisal procedures vary by state and by policy language.
Questions about your situation?
Fair, reasonable, and independent. We form our own opinion and go from there.